Middle-earth: Shadow of War Guide – How to make Warchiefs into spies

In Middle-earth: Shadow of War, the Nemesis System is king. Once you’re able to dominate Orcs, you can recruit Captains, make them spies and make your battles easier.

When you’re trying to overthrow a Warlord, it makes sense that you’d want to have his Warchiefs in your pocket. But how do you make Warchiefs into spies? If you target them in a mission and dominate them, they lose their position as a Warchief and will be replaced by another, loyal to the Warlord.

There’s even an Achievement/Trophy tied into making all of a Warlord’s Warchiefs into spies. The Nemesis System may be king, but it’s pretty obtuse and not everything is explained to the player. Thankfully, we’ve got it figured out for you.

Make Warchiefs into Spies

Making Warchiefs into spies is actually pretty easy, it’s just not explained or intuitive. When an enemy Warlord holds a fort you’ll need to either kill or Dominate the Warchief to remove him from his position. You’ll need to make sure you have some dominated Orcs in the army for that region too.

Once you’ve removed the enemy Warchief and his spot is empty, choose the Orc Captain you want to make a spy. Press Triangle or Y to Command him and then select the empty spot. Choose Infiltrate and then your Captain will be promoted to Warchief.

I’ve unfortunately finished the game and own all forts, so I couldn’t get screenshots of an enemy fort. Rest assured, the same way you make a Captin spy on a Warchief, is how you make a Warchief into a spy. You just don’t need to go through the added step of watching a Pit Fight.


Middle-earth: Shadow of War is available now.

Enter our competition to win a copy here. 

Leo Stevenson
Leo Stevensonhttps://powerup-gaming.com/
I've been playing games for the past 27 years and have been writing for almost as long. Combining two passions in the way I'm able is a true privilege. PowerUp! is a labour of love and one I am so excited to share.

━ more like this

This Day in Aussie Gaming: The High Stakes All-Timers of Apr 2

Gaming is an ever-evolving medium, but some days in history stand out as pivotal moments in its journey. Whether it's a groundbreaking movie tie-in...

Warfare Review (2025) – An Unflinching, Harrowing, Claustrophic Nightmare

Warfare, from Writer-Director (and Iraq War Veteran) Ray Mendoza and Alex Garland (Ex Machina, Civil War), is a towering achievement in cinema. Following in the footsteps...

This Day in Aussie Gaming: The Whip-Cracking Goodness of Mar 31

Every game launch is a moment in time—a snapshot of where gaming was, what players craved, and how technology was evolving. Some titles push...

MobLand Review (TV – 2025) – I Think We Have a Situation Developing

Mobland is why we watch TV. Right from the word go, it's a perfectly paced masterpiece of tone, acting and filmmaking...at least from the...

Alienware AW2725Q Review: The Best Value 4K OLED Gaming Monitor?

Alienware offers the cheapest 27-inch 4K OLED gaming monitor in a sleek package that is tough to beat.